Business groups have broadly welcomed Alan Milburn’s plan to tackle Britain’s NEET crisis. But one message runs through almost every response: young people will not get their first chance unless it becomes cheaper and simpler for employers, especially small firms, to give it to them.
Almost a million 16 to 24-year-olds in the UK are not in education, employment or training (NEET). The state spends £22bn a year on economically inactive young people. Former Health Secretary Alan Milburn’s final review into young people and work, published on Tuesday 17 November, calls for “a complete system reset” and warns that “half measures will not do”.
Its headline ambition, dubbed “NEET Zero”, is to cut the NEET rate from 13% to around 5% by 2036. The review estimates its reforms would help around 440,000 young people into work and add roughly 0.4% to GDP a year by then.
What the review proposes
The recommendations most relevant to employers include:
- An Opportunity Guarantee in law, offering every under-25 an apprenticeship, college place, job coaching or a job, with benefits cut for those who refuse
- Lower National Insurance for young workers, raising the employer threshold for 21 to 24-year-olds from £5,000 to £10,000 over five years, starting with retail and hospitality. That saves up to £750 a year per employee
- Bigger hiring grants, with the £3,000 Youth Jobs Grant extended to anyone NEET for six months, plus £2,000 more for firms with fewer than 50 staff
- Apprenticeship changes, including fully funded under-25 apprenticeships, a hiring payment up from £2,000 to £2,500, and ending the Treasury’s topslice of levy receipts. Employers would pay 25% more towards apprenticeships for over-25s
- A statutory Youth Opportunity Test for major government decisions
- A digital gateway and a local Youth Opportunity Service, so a small business can find every scheme in one place. As the report puts it, “A small business should not need to understand the architecture of the state in order to employ a young person”
- Low or no-cost insurance for very small firms offering work experience
The Government has moved quickly on the headline measures. In a Commons statement, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said ministers support the Opportunity and Support Guarantees and the shift to locally delivered support. A new Youth Opportunities Unit will report directly to the Prime Minister, and a White Paper will follow in the new year. Ministers have not yet said whether they will adopt the National Insurance and apprenticeship funding proposals.
Small firms: “cannot come soon enough”
The Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) gave one of the warmest responses. National Chair Tina McKenzie said: “Alan Milburn is right to recognise that getting more young people into work means making it easier, not
harder, for businesses to employ them. Small firms want to give young people their first chance, but rising employment costs and mounting regulation are making that increasingly difficult.”
She said the National Insurance cut for firms hiring 21 to 24-year-olds “cannot come soon enough”. The FSB also welcomed bigger financial incentives for small employers, and the review’s adoption of its call to extend the Youth Guarantee to young entrepreneurs. “FSB research shows that while 58 per cent of young people own or are interested in owning a business, just 16 per cent currently run one,” McKenzie said. “There’s a huge pool of entrepreneurial talent waiting to be tapped.”
But she echoed Milburn’s warning that the Government must also “do less harm”, including in “upcoming regulatory decisions, such as with zero hours contracts”.
Chambers: right goal, wrong price tag
The London Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LCCI) was the most outspoken. It backs the 5% target but
warns the plan will fail unless hiring gets cheaper. “The Government must accept all of Milburn’s recommendations, including reducing the cost of hiring a young person for businesses,” said Chief Executive Karim Fatehi OBE. “It cannot pick and choose which recommendations it supports.”
Fatehi added: “The Government cannot spend another decade creating new services, targets and schemes while not addressing the reason businesses are holding back from hiring.”
LCCI’s research with YouGov, covering more than 500 employers and over 1,000 young people, suggests employers are willing:
- 61% of employers would hire a young person with no work history at all
- 58% say removing employer National Insurance for under-25s would help their business
- 53% are more likely to hire someone with a completed apprenticeship, against 45% for a degree
- Only 7% say young people arrive with all the skills their business needs, while 38% say they arrive with few or none
LCCI wants employer National Insurance scrapped for every worker under 25, which it says would save £3,000 a year on a £25,000 salary. It is also calling for a £15,000 Employment Allowance for firms that take on an under-25, and for apprenticeships to be tax-free. “No Government can subsidise a million young people back into work,” said Head of Policy Aaron Walker. “Employers want to hire and young people want to work.”
The British Chambers of Commerce struck a similar note. Director General Shevaun Haviland said rising
employment costs have made firms “much more cautious on recruitment”. She said the missing piece is “properly tackling the costs of creating the jobs needed”. She welcomed the National Insurance glide path but wants it “sooner rather than later”. She also warned that charging firms more to train over-25s “will simply discourage investment in them”.
HR profession: a deal needs two sides
Neil Carberry, chief executive of the CIPD, said Milburn “has got a key diagnosis right: tackling youth unemployment isn’t just about improving young people’s skills; it’s about giving employers the confidence and incentives to take a chance on young people.”
He warned that the proposed “new deal” between state and employers must cut both ways. “Government cannot simply outsource the risk of success onto employers,” he said. “Sustainable jobs rest on successful employers who can afford to take someone on.”
Carberry called the National Insurance proposal “the right step” but “complex”. He argued that “a bigger bang, and a fairer approach for all employers would be restoring the wider threshold towards its previous £9,100 level”. He welcomed the Youth Opportunity Test, but said it should be used immediately on Employment Rights Act 2025 measures not yet in force. “Zero hours contracts are a crucial entry point to work for young people, and half a million depend on them.”
He called the pre-apprenticeship pathway, levy reinvestment and the £2,500 wage incentive “the right calls”. He added that “the profit margin the Treasury has been taking on Levy payments not routed towards the system is scandalous”. But he cautioned that asking employers to pay more towards older workers’ apprenticeships risks “some employers cutting back on learning for older workers”.
Engineering: “skills are pointless without jobs”
Enginuity, the skills charity that works with engineering and manufacturing SMEs, welcomed the review’s direction. But it warned that technical sectors risk being left behind.
“Alan Milburn rightly says that Government cannot ask business to create more first opportunities while ignoring
the effect its own decisions have on whether those opportunities are viable,” said Enginuity CEO Ann Watson MBE. “This report risks not going further, faster – and that failure lands on the very young people it promises to help.”
Her central concern is apprenticeship funding. “You can promise 100% funding for an under-25 apprenticeship, but if the funding band makes a specialist engineering standard uneconomic for a training provider to deliver, that opportunity simply won’t exist.”
The sector has more than 40,000 vacancies. Enginuity estimates skills gaps cost the economy £5.2bn a year. Because the National Insurance relief starts with retail and hospitality, Watson wants engineering and manufacturing “included from the outset”. She also wants a review of apprenticeship funding bands. “A youth guarantee is only meaningful if there is an employer at the other end able to provide the opportunity,” she said. “The ambition is right. The test now is whether Government makes recruitment and training viable for the businesses needed to deliver it.”
Enginuity’s wider asks include shared apprenticeship models, help with the cost of mentoring and supervision, and a Skills Tax Credit to protect investment in adult skills.
Entrepreneurship: listen to what young people want
Oliver Harcourt, UK director of Taxfix, urged policymakers not to overlook self-employment. “Our definition of opportunity needs to be as broad as young people’s ambitions and interests, and that means self-employment and entrepreneurship as well as a typical 9 to 5,” he said.
New Taxfix research found that more than a third of 11 to 18-year-olds already earn money from side hustles. Almost two-thirds want to work for themselves one day, and 91% want more practical business and financial education at school. “Learning how to spot an opportunity, understand costs, manage money and find customers gives young people skills they’ll use wherever their careers take them,” Harcourt said. “If we want to engage young people, surely we should start by listening to what they’re telling us they want to learn?”
Health, wellbeing and joined-up services
Others stressed that many barriers to work sit outside the workplace. Michelle Kujawa, Global Learning &
Performance Consultant at Reward Gateway | Edenred, said: “Mental health challenges, financial pressures and a lack of access to appropriate support can all affect someone’s confidence and ability to enter and remain in work.” She urged employers to offer mental health resources and financial wellbeing support. “Supporting people early, rather than waiting until they reach crisis point, is not only better for individuals but can also help businesses build healthier, more resilient and productive teams.”
Rich Lum, Senior Partner at Newton, said early identification of young people at risk will be among the hardest recommendations to deliver. “Each service in the system that supports NEETs holds only part of the information,” he said. “We need to be able to connect data currently siloed across schools, health, welfare and social care to identify young people at risk.” The challenge, he added, is to make sure local success “isn’t confined to isolated pockets”.
Stephen Evans, chief executive of the Learning and Work Institute, said Milburn “is
right to call for a fundamental reset”. But he cautioned that “cutting National Insurance may prove costly and complicated”. He also said the plan’s reliance on mayors will only work if they have real powers.
What it means for SMEs
The review puts small firms at the centre of its plan, calling them “indispensable to any serious expansion of first jobs”. If adopted in full, the measures would give a small employer:
- £5,000 for firms with fewer than 50 staff that hire a young person who has been NEET for six months, rising to £7,000 for young people facing greater barriers
- A £2,500 payment for each apprentice aged 16 to 24, with training fully funded
- Up to £750 a year in lower National Insurance per 21 to 24-year-old employee, initially in retail and hospitality only
- One digital front door to all of these schemes, and cheaper insurance cover for work experience placements
But little of this is law yet. The Government has backed the guarantees and the new local service. It has not committed to the National Insurance cut, the higher grants or the apprenticeship funding changes. Those are the measures employers say matter most.
The next milestones are the Timms Review, due shortly, and a White Paper in the new year, with legislation to follow. The verdict from business is consistent. The diagnosis is right and the ambition is welcome. Whether the plan works will depend on the cost of hiring a young person, and on how quickly ministers act on it.
Sources
- Work and Pensions Secretary statement on the Milburn review, GOV.UK
- Milburn Review deep dive: what the final report means for FE and skills, FE News
- Alan Milburn’s NEETs report: what’s in it for small businesses, SME Web
- Milburn welcome but hiring issues remain, British Chambers of Commerce
- Responding to the Milburn Review, Learning and Work Institute
- Supplied statements: LCCI, FSB, CIPD, Enginuity, Taxfix, Reward Gateway | Edenred, Newton
