Close Menu
  • News
  • Home
  • In Profile
  • Finance
  • Legal
  • Technology
  • Events
  • Features
  • Wellbeing & Mental Health
  • Marketing
  • HR & Recruitment
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Events Calendar
  • Business Wall
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • 0843 289 4634
X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube
Trending
  • I’ve been in employee benefits a long time: it’s about time we supported SMEs
  • SMEs say funding is vital – so why are a third not applying?
  • The CEO of Nothing. Why You Should Avoid ‘Gurus’
  • Can an ex-employee be silenced by an NDA in 2025?
  • E-Invoicing: The Lifeline UK Small Businesses Can’t Afford to Ignore
  • Social care experts launch an online marketplace to disrupt a sector in crisis.
  • Are SMEs getting better at embracing good cybersecurity practices?
  • Universities partner with Made Smarter to deliver fast-track digital leadership programme for SME manufacturers
X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube
SME Today
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Events Calendar
  • Business Wall
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • 0843 289 4634
  • News
  • Home
  • In Profile
  • Finance
  • Legal
  • Technology
  • Events
  • Features
  • Wellbeing
  • Marketing
  • HR & Recruitment
SME Today
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Events Calendar
  • Business Wall
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • 0843 289 4634
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • RSS
You are at:Home»Legal»An Online Solution to an Age Old Problem – Online Dispute Resolution for Debt Claims
Unpaid invoices

An Online Solution to an Age Old Problem – Online Dispute Resolution for Debt Claims

0
Posted By sme-admin on September 29, 2022 Features, Legal

The problem of unpaid invoices is probably at least as old as invoices themselves (give or take 28 days for payment). In the vast majority of cases, bills are raised and bills are paid – most of them promptly and within the payment terms.

When invoices are not paid the problem invariably falls into two camps: (1) can’t pay; and/or (2) won’t pay.

Can’t pay is normally a more difficult problem to resolve and to an extent can be mitigated against, by for example, seeking payment in advance of services or running credit checks.  Troublingly but inevitably, sometimes “can’t pay” is dressed up as “wont pay” likely in order to buy the debtor more time or to try and discourage the other party from pursuing the debt.

When it comes to won’t pay, the debt is disputed and ultimately if a resolution cannot be found, the debt will either have to be written off as a bad debt or will come before a Judge to decide. Even on the most straightforward case if a dispute over an unpaid debt gets to trial and the parties have engaged lawyers, legal costs can often exceed the sums in dispute. Taking a dispute £50,000 where the claimant is successful, assuming costs of half the value of the dispute (i.e. £25,000) are incurred on each side, the debtor could easily end up paying £100,000 taking into account (a) paying their own costs; (b) a percentage of the claimant’s costs; and (c) interest.

Online Dispute Resolution

Online dispute resolution in some shape or form has often been lauded as a solution to the “litigation problem” of  costs and delay. The Courts have in recent years moved to a fully online filing system for most High Court claims and modes of commencing and even managing certain claims online.  An online element for dispute resolution is a clearly emerging trend with some very prominent backers including some senior judges.

Recently a proof of concept published by LawtechUK has advanced a platform which would aim to resolve an unpaid debt claim within eight weeks and without the traditional adversarial process as an alternative to the Court route.  Crucially the process would be voluntary albeit it is envisaged that it would be preferably agreed in advance via standard terms and conditions  – effectively imposed on the party receiving goods/services as a matter of course.

LawtechUK have stated that “[o]ptimal cases for the platform are those of a pure payment dispute in nature, without complex issues of fact, and where the parties are engaging on an elective basis…” with an “…anticipated range of case value is at the lower end – hundreds of pounds up to low tens of thousands…”.

The Platform would be built to take the users through a process which sets out the parameters of the dispute, focuses on the key issues via a “Settlement Builder” giving opportunities to reach agreement. If consensus is not reached in the platform then provided certain requirements are met, the platform funnels into a mediation which, if turned down or unsuccessful, results in an adjudication of the dispute with a binding decision which would be legally enforceable, with a direct link to the Court for that process.

Online -v- Traditional  

Costs of litigating a debt claim can be disproportionately high and can be a barrier to enforcement. Those costs are however often driven by the issues (which (rightly or wrongly) would simply not get the same prominence via this model).

A significantly streamlined process which is intended to be party driven, with lawyers (if engaged) operating only in the background, is likely to significantly reduce expense but that will come at the cost of a detailed forensic scrutiny of the issues (both factual and legal). If the Platform comes to fruition in its current guise it will provide a workable, quick and easy route to resolve simple disputes but it may feel like fast and loose justice too – particularly for the losing party (notwithstanding the focus on resolution over determination).

The platform’s architect is (as it ought to be) optimistic about the proportion of payment disputes which will be resolved between the parties through agreement without the need for a determination. The sceptical lawyers amongst us may be concerned that a low risk route to disputing debts may have the unintended opposite effect of defendants rolling the dice on a trumped up reason not to pay and hoping for the best. There is nothing quite like a risk of paying the other side’s legal costs on top of the debt as a deterrent against maintaining (for too long at least) unwinnable arguments.

If done correctly and limited to the “optimal” type of dispute then a Court-linked online dispute resolution platform will service a great deal of disputes which ought never to end up going through legal proceedings.

But parties should be careful to consider whether it is the right forum for their dispute. With a wide-scope programme introducing fixed recoverability for legal costs for most disputes of less than £100,000 scheduled to come into force in April 2023; more cost effective traditional looking routes to legal proceedings will soon be available. Reform via either route is likely to disrupt the market and broaden the options available to would-be litigants.

Liam Tolen – Senior Associate – Ashfords LLP

 

 

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

Related Posts

The CEO of Nothing. Why You Should Avoid ‘Gurus’

Can an ex-employee be silenced by an NDA in 2025?

The Digital Trap: Why Cancelling Online Subscriptions Is Still Needlessly Difficult in the UK

Comments are closed.

Follow SME Today on Linkedin and share all the topics you find interesting
Invest in your pension

The Newsletter

Join our mailing list for the best SME stories, handpicked and delivered direct to your inbox every two weeks!

Sign Up
Events Calendar
    • Marketing
    May 6, 2025

    Why WordPress Remains One of the Best Website Platforms for Entrepreneurs

    May 1, 2025

    New initiative offers UK small businesses rare opportunity to secure national TV advertising with Channel 4 worth £300,000

    • Finance
    May 16, 2025

    SMEs say funding is vital – so why are a third not applying?

    May 15, 2025

    E-Invoicing: The Lifeline UK Small Businesses Can’t Afford to Ignore

    • Health & Safety
    January 29, 2025

    UK takeaways guilty of shocking hygiene failures:

    December 18, 2024

    Comment on Covid Corruption Commissioner Investigation

    • Events
    November 19, 2024

    Seventeenth Global Entrepreneurship Week (GEW)

    October 22, 2024

    Winners Announced for Sheffield Business Awards 2024

    • Community
    May 14, 2025

    Social care experts launch an online marketplace to disrupt a sector in crisis.

    May 1, 2025

    A Marathon Effort: Managing Director Raises Over £4,000 for Charity

    • Food & Drink
    April 16, 2025

    Cutting Down on Business Costs in Your Cafe

    April 15, 2025

    Allergy Awareness Advocate Julianne Ponan MBE To Address Gousto   

    • Books
    April 24, 2025

    Values-Driven Professionalism: A Path to Client Loyalty

    December 2, 2024

    Banish the banshee boss: how to lead without fear – addressing the issue of fear-based management and how NOT to be this manager

    About

    SME Today is published by the same team who deliver The Great British Expos’. We have been organising various corporate events for the last 10 years, with a strong track record of producing well managed and attended business events across the UK.

    Join Our Mailing List

    Receive the latest news and updates from SMEToday.
    Read our Latest Newsletter:


    Sign Up
    X (Twitter) YouTube LinkedIn
    Most Recent Posts
    May 19, 2025

    I’ve been in employee benefits a long time: it’s about time we supported SMEs

    May 16, 2025

    SMEs say funding is vital – so why are a third not applying?

    May 16, 2025

    The CEO of Nothing. Why You Should Avoid ‘Gurus’

    May 15, 2025

    Can an ex-employee be silenced by an NDA in 2025?

    May 15, 2025

    E-Invoicing: The Lifeline UK Small Businesses Can’t Afford to Ignore

    Categories
    • Books
    • Community & Charity
    • Education and Training
    • Environment
    • Events
    • Features
    • Finance
    • Food and Drink
    • Health & Safety
    • HR & Recruitment
    • In Profile
    • Legal
    • Marketing
    • News
    • Property & Development
    • Sponsored Content
    • Technology
    • Transport & Tourism
    • Wellbeing & Mental Health

    Copyright © 2020 SME Today.

    • ABOUT SME TODAY: THE GO TO RESOURCE FOR UK BUSINESSES
    • Privacy
    • Contact
    Copyright © 2025 SME Today.
    • ABOUT SME TODAY: THE GO TO RESOURCE FOR UK BUSINESSES
    • Privacy
    • Contact

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.