• News
  • Home
  • In Profile
  • Finance
  • Legal
  • Technology
  • Events
  • Features
  • Well Being
  • Marketing
  • HR & Recruitment
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Events Calendar
  • Business Wall
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • 0843 289 4634
Twitter LinkedIn YouTube
Trending
  • Document Management Company Celebrating Award Success For Third Consecutive Year
  • Podcast advertising: A lesser-known secret to marketing success
  • 7 effective tips for achieving a better work-life balance as a self-employed professional
  • Education and Culture: Tools against workplace stress
  • Ensuring Ethical AI Practices Tailored to Your Industry’s Needs
  • European Business Lenders Forecast Spiralling Fraud Rates
  • Autumn Statement sparks SME hope, but there is more work to be done
  • Why Too Much Ego is Disastrous in a Transformation Project
Twitter LinkedIn YouTube
SME Today
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Events Calendar
  • Business Wall
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • 0843 289 4634
  • News
  • Home
  • In Profile
  • Finance
  • Legal
  • Technology
  • Events
  • Features
  • Wellbeing
  • Marketing
  • HR & Recruitment
SME Today
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Events Calendar
  • Business Wall
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • 0843 289 4634
You are at:Home»Legal»What does the consultation on holiday pay laws for part time workers mean for SMEs
Holiday pay

What does the consultation on holiday pay laws for part time workers mean for SMEs

0
By sme-admin on March 20, 2023 HR & Recruitment, Legal

Most HR practitioners knew it was coming but when the Supreme Court issued its long-awaited decision in Harpur Trust v Brazel on 20 July 2022 there was a collective groan in many sectors such as retail and hospitality. While the decision did not affect salaried workers or those on fixed term or fixed part time hours, it still affected potentially between 320,000 and 500,000 permanent term-time and zero-hours workers such as sales assistants or warehouse staff and between 80,000 and 200,000 agency workers.

Kate Palka - The Legal DirectorDispute

The dispute in the case centred around the application of the simple 5.6 weeks’ holiday allowance for everyone set out in the UK’s Working Time Regulations and illustrated that this is no longer workable because it cannot easily be translated into hours or days for workers whose hours vary and does not include principles for pro-rating.

Ruling

The Court ruled that employers cannot apportion part-year workers’ 5.6 weeks to the part of the year they worked, if they are under contract for the whole year. Instead, employers must calculate a week’s holiday pay by using the calendar method, averaging the last 52 weeks in which the part-year worker actually carried out work; discounting the weeks in which they did not work in order to calculate a week’s holiday pay. The previous traditional method of calculating holiday entitlement by applying 12.07% to the hours actually worked became unlawful.

Fall out

While the Supreme Court’s reasoning on the law was sound, it created an anomaly which resulted in atypical workers being entitled to receive disproportionately more holiday. A specialist on the payroll who works over three weeks a year and is on zero pay for the rest of the year, for example, was entitled to 5.6 weeks’ holiday, paid at the rate of their average weekly earnings in the three weeks they worked, which is the same entitlement as a colleague who works all year round.

The decision also created a significant administrative burden. Think of the hotel employer with 70 students on the payroll who pick and choose shifts during term times. Whereas previously, they simply multiplied hours worked by 12.07%, they would now need to record every hour worked over a period of 104 weeks just to calculate the average hours for holiday pay.

Following Harpur, many businesses worked quickly to change the calculation method they used and to quantify potential historical underpayments of holiday pay. Others reconsidered their use of permanent contracts where employees worked for only part of the year.  Others may have had to budget for higher agency fees as recruitment agencies increased the holiday accrual rates from 12.07% to a higher figure.

Government consultation

On 12 January 2023 the Government launched a consultation stating that they were keen to fix the disparity and make it is easier for employers to comply with the law by simplifying the holiday pay and entitlement rules.

Proposals

First, the Government is proposing that statutory holiday entitlement be pro-rated, so that part year workers and those with irregular hours receive leave proportionate to their total annual hours worked. To reflect that principle, it suggests that employers should calculate an individual’s holiday entitlement at the start of each holiday year by looking back at the hours they worked in the last complete holiday year. They would then multiply last year’s hours by 12.07% to get next year’s holiday entitlement, resulting in a fixed pot for the worker.

In the first year of employment, where there is no fixed reference period, an accrual method is proposed under which employers would need, at the end of each month, to calculate 12.07% of hours worked in that month.

Notably, this would be the first legislative endorsement of the 12.07% method. Previously it had been widely adopted by employers but with no legal basis for using it.

This method does raise a potential issue about how to treat the holiday entitlement gained in the twelfth month as it is only calculated at the end of the year. Employers would have to decide whether to allow it to be taken before it accrues or to be carried over to the next leave year.

Agency workers are covered: they would accrue holiday entitlement on the basis of 12.07% of hours worked at the end of each month of an assignment, or at the end of an assignment if shorter than a month.

The consultation also tackles the question of how to calculate a day’s leave, to rectify the current lack of clarity about how much leave a variable hours worker uses up to take a day off.  The proposal is that if such a worker wanted a day off, employers would work out how many hours of their holiday entitlement this would use up by reference to a flat average working day so that, for example, each day’s leave would use up six or seven hours of the leave pot.

It should be noted that the proposals only relate to calculating entitlement. Holiday pay will continue to be based on a different reference period (the last 52 paid weeks, on a rolling basis, rather than all weeks over the last holiday year) and would still be calculated in weeks without any system for translating this into days or hours.

Drawbacks

The practicalities of how an employer can keep an accurate record of hours worked looking backwards may be challenging. The proposals will result in the introduction of a new category of worker who is “part year” or on “irregular hours”, which will have to be defined. The consultation does not deal with accrual of holiday for those on maternity leave or other family leave, which might clash with the proposed fifty-two-week reference period.  Also, there may well be simpler calculation methods, for example a straightforward accrual system, where individuals build up holiday entitlement for each year at 12.07% of every hour worked that year.

Nonetheless, the consultation (which closed on 9 March) should result in legislation that clarifies the current confused position.  Until then, the Supreme Court’s judgment remains binding law. Businesses that did not make changes after Harpur may now decide to await the outcome of the consultation, while recognising the potential exposure to claims of underpayment by their current part year or irregular hours workers.

Author: Kate Palka, employment and commercial solicitor from The Legal Director.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

Related Posts

Stamping out sexual harassment in the workplace

Own your SME status: Your secret weapon when recruiting!

The Fenton Elliott Business Book Club

Comments are closed.

Follow SME Today on Linkedin and share all the topics you find interesting

The Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from SMEToday
Read our Latest Newsletter:

Sign Up
Events Calendar
    • Marketing
    November 24, 2023

    Ten Red Flags to Look for When Hiring a Marketing Agency in 2024

    November 13, 2023

    The Power of a Name – Expert Tips for Naming Your Business

    • Finance
    November 29, 2023

    European Business Lenders Forecast Spiralling Fraud Rates

    November 27, 2023

    Autumn Statement sparks SME hope, but there is more work to be done

    Protean Inbound Marketing
    • Health & Safety
    November 21, 2023

    Fire Safety: How to Protect Your Business With 5 Simple Steps

    September 5, 2023

    The Importance of Preventing Falls in the Workplace

    Discover Maximizer
    Discover Maximiser
    • Events
    November 15, 2023

    The Great Christmas Raffle Raising Vital Funds For Charities

    September 28, 2023

    Brighton Half Marathon Youth Races Returning in 2024

    • Community
    November 17, 2023

    Cherishers 811 CIC Wins Bronze & Silver Stevie® Award In 2023 Stevie Awards For Women In Business

    November 15, 2023

    The Great Christmas Raffle Raising Vital Funds For Charities

    • Food & Drink
    November 8, 2023

    Brownie business reaches ‘epic’ proportions with support from Delivered UK and The APC network

    August 8, 2023

    London’s Remote Work Coffee Shop Guide: work-friendly independents and small chains closest to every tube stop in London’s Zone 1

    • Books
    November 27, 2023

    Why Too Much Ego is Disastrous in a Transformation Project

    November 16, 2023

    The Fenton Elliott Business Book Club

    About

    SME Today is published by the same team who deliver The Great British Expos’. We have been organising various corporate events for the last 10 years, with a strong track record of producing well managed and attended business events across the UK.

    Join Our Mailing List

    Receive the latest news and updates from SMEToday.
    Read our Latest Newsletter:


    Sign Up
    Twitter YouTube LinkedIn
    Most Recent Posts
    November 30, 2023

    Document Management Company Celebrating Award Success For Third Consecutive Year

    November 30, 2023

    Podcast advertising: A lesser-known secret to marketing success

    November 29, 2023

    7 effective tips for achieving a better work-life balance as a self-employed professional

    November 29, 2023

    Education and Culture: Tools against workplace stress

    November 29, 2023

    Ensuring Ethical AI Practices Tailored to Your Industry’s Needs

    Categories
    • Books
    • Community
    • Education and Training
    • Environment
    • Events
    • Features
    • Finance
    • Food and Drink
    • Health & Safety
    • HR & Recruitment
    • In Profile
    • Legal
    • Marketing
    • News
    • Property & Development
    • Sponsored Content
    • Technology
    • Transport
    • Well Being
    Copyright © 2020 SME Today.
    • ABOUT SME TODAY: THE GO TO RESOURCE FOR UK BUSINESSES
    • Privacy
    • Contact

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.