Close Menu
  • News
  • Home
  • In Profile
  • Finance
  • Legal
  • Technology
  • Events
  • Features
  • Wellbeing & Mental Health
  • Marketing
  • HR & Recruitment
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Events Calendar
  • Business Wall
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • 0843 289 4634
X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube
Trending
  • Dementia Advocate Shares Tips For Supporting People With Dementia When Flying
  • SME Today talks to Sa’ed Anabtawi, Product Director, WOLF
  • The Truth Behind ‘Sickies’
  • Five ways to monetise your business EV chargers
  • New book on conquering fear of public speaking
  • 1 in 3 employees anxious about lack of first aiders at work
  • What SMEs risk when their IT provider gets bought out
  • Back to Work: Keeping your employees happy after their holiday high 
X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube
SME Today
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Events Calendar
  • Business Wall
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • 0843 289 4634
  • News
  • Home
  • In Profile
  • Finance
  • Legal
  • Technology
  • Events
  • Features
  • Wellbeing
  • Marketing
  • HR & Recruitment
SME Today
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Events Calendar
  • Business Wall
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • 0843 289 4634
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • RSS
You are at:Home»HR & Recruitment»Make Work Pay Bill Criticised as ‘Rushed and Chaotic’ and Could Threaten Jobs and Economic Growth, Say Small Firms
Make Work Pay

Make Work Pay Bill Criticised as ‘Rushed and Chaotic’ and Could Threaten Jobs and Economic Growth, Say Small Firms

0
Posted By Greg Robinson on October 10, 2024 HR & Recruitment, News

The Government’s introduction of the “Make Work Pay” bill has drawn sharp criticism from small businesses and employment law experts. The bill, which includes 28 new measures aimed at reforming employment rights, is being viewed as rushed and poorly planned. Concerns are being raised about its potential to impact employment rates, job creation, and economic growth.

A “Rushed Job” That Threatens Small Businesses

FSB policy Chair Tina McKenzieTina McKenzie, Policy Chair at the Federation of Small Businesses (FSB), has been one of the most outspoken critics of the bill. She called it a “rushed job, clumsy, chaotic, and poorly planned,” highlighting how the introduction of 28 new measures at once has left small business employers struggling to understand and adapt to the changes. McKenzie pointed out that the bill lacks a clear pro-growth component, which could lead to increased economic inactivity and threaten the Government’s employment target of 80%.

“There are already 65,000 fewer payroll jobs since Labour took power, and the new Government is sending out a troubling signal to businesses and investors,” McKenzie said.

McKenzie emphasised that small firms are often the employers who give opportunities to individuals farthest from the labour market, such as those returning after long-term health issues or caring responsibilities. She warned that the new legislation could discourage small employers from hiring people who have had significant periods out of work, potentially worsening social exclusion. The additional employment costs brought about by the bill, she argued, could hinder job creation and negatively affect growth and investment.

McKenzie also pointed out that the Chancellor has an opportunity to introduce more pro-business measures to the bill, such as raising the Employment Allowance and reinstating the small business rebate for Statutory Sick Pay. She expressed concerns about the forthcoming consultation on zero-hours contracts and urged the Government to consider the needs of seasonal small businesses and struggling sectors like hospitality and tourism. “Sufficient time should be taken to avoid this becoming a hastily cobbled-together Act of Parliament,” McKenzie added.

Concerns Over Increased Employment Rights

Chris Cuckeny, Senior Associate at Devonshires, commented that while the introduction of more employment rights might be welcome news for employees, it could have significant implications for businesses. He said, Chris Cuckeny, Senior Associate at Devonshires“Whilst more employment rights will be welcome news for individuals, for businesses the new Employment Rights Bill will be received with some trepidation as it reduces their flexibility in being able to manage their workforce whilst, at the same time, increasing their financial obligations.”

Cuckeny highlighted that the inclusion of day-one unfair dismissal rights could make businesses more hesitant to hire, potentially affecting employment rates and economic growth. He also pointed out the strain this could put on the already overwhelmed Employment Tribunal system, which is facing severe backlogs. “Employment Tribunals are desperately backlogged, with hearings in certain parts of the country already being listed into Summer 2026. Giving employees more rights will inevitably increase the number of legal claims issued, and without substantial investment from the Government to increase resources, these new rights risk overwhelming a Tribunal system that is already on its knees.”

Significant Employment Law Changes

Kate Palmer, Employment Services Director at Peninsula, provided an overview of the key changes in the Make Work Pay bill. She noted that the Government had kept its pledge to bring legislation to Parliament within 100 days of coming into power, which marks the first significant step in implementing Labour’s “Make Work Pay” Kate Palmer, Employment Services Directorplan.

“Possibly the most significant inclusion is the planned introduction of a day-one right to unfair dismissal protection,” Palmer explained. This proposal is accompanied by a commitment to consult on a statutory probation period of nine months. While full unfair dismissal protection would not apply during this period, employers would need to reassess their “early exit” procedures. “Employers will have a much shorter period to decide on the suitability of an employee before having to engage in what can be lengthy formal procedures to fairly dismiss an employee,” Palmer said.

Palmer also highlighted other major changes in the bill, including a ban on “fire and rehire” practices except in extreme circumstances, the right for zero-hours staff to switch to guaranteed hours contracts if they work regular hours, and an extension of the right to flexible working from day one. Additional rights such as statutory sick pay from the first day of absence, statutory bereavement leave, and day-one rights to parental leave are also part of the new measures.

Palmer cautioned that employers will need to review their contracts, policies, and procedures to comply with the upcoming changes. “Employers should prepare for huge change and ensure they keep on top of every twist and turn so that they can swiftly take action to remain legally compliant,” she said.

Conclusion: Call for More Engagement and Consultation

The introduction of the Make Work Pay bill, while designed to enhance employment rights, has raised concerns about its potential impact on small businesses and the economy. Critics like Tina McKenzie and Chris Cuckeny have urged the Government to take a more measured approach, highlighting the need for more consultation and engagement with small business owners.

As McKenzie concluded, “We look forward to more engagement and the start of a full consultation on each individual measure to ensure the voice of small employers is heard.”

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email

Related Posts

Dementia Advocate Shares Tips For Supporting People With Dementia When Flying

The Truth Behind ‘Sickies’

Back to Work: Keeping your employees happy after their holiday high 

Comments are closed.

Follow SME Today on Linkedin and share all the topics you find interesting

The Newsletter

Join our mailing list for the best SME stories, handpicked and delivered direct to your inbox every two weeks!

Sign Up
Personal Pension offer
Events Calendar
    • Marketing
    August 29, 2025

    OneMetric forms strategic partnership with RevOps expert to drive UK growth

    August 28, 2025

    The Seven Phases of Festive Shopping and How to Target within Each Effectively

    • Finance
    September 3, 2025

    Five ways to monetise your business EV chargers

    September 1, 2025

    Are you flying blind on your most important business decisions?

    • People
    August 14, 2025

    A Life Worth Saving – A Tribute to Dame Stephanie Shirley CH, 1933–2025

    August 12, 2025

    Finance Director Returns As Judge For National Business Awards

    • Health & Safety
    September 2, 2025

    1 in 3 employees anxious about lack of first aiders at work

    July 1, 2025

    Temperatures Soaring: Is Your Workplace Becoming Unsafe?

    • Events
    July 22, 2025

    South West Expo Delivers Outstanding Event at Swindon’s STEAM Museum

    July 4, 2025

    £20k grant for female-founded SME up for grabs

    • Community
    July 11, 2025

    Building community, one cause at a time

    June 23, 2025

    Celebrating One Year In Fairford Supporting The Community

    • Food & Drink
    August 22, 2025

    How to get stocked by major retailers as an SME

    July 18, 2025

    Warning to Small Businesses Over New Food Waste Regulations

    • Books
    September 3, 2025

    New book on conquering fear of public speaking

    August 7, 2025

    Learning to Leave a Legacy in Business

    About

    SME Today is published by the same team who deliver The Great British Expos’. We have been organising various corporate events for the last 10 years, with a strong track record of producing well managed and attended business events across the UK.

    Join Our Mailing List

    Receive the latest news and updates from SMEToday.
    Read our Latest Newsletter:


    Sign Up
    X (Twitter) YouTube LinkedIn
    Categories
    • Books
    • Community & Charity
    • Education and Training
    • Environment
    • Events
    • Features
    • Finance
    • Food and Drink
    • Health & Safety
    • HR & Recruitment
    • In Profile
    • Legal
    • Marketing
    • News
    • People
    • Property & Development
    • Sponsored Content
    • Technology
    • Transport & Tourism
    • Wellbeing & Mental Health
    • ABOUT SME TODAY: THE GO TO RESOURCE FOR UK BUSINESSES
    • Editorial Submission Guidelines
    • Privacy
    • Contact
    Copyright © 2025 SME Today.
    • ABOUT SME TODAY: THE GO TO RESOURCE FOR UK BUSINESSES
    • Editorial Submission Guidelines
    • Privacy
    • Contact

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.